When you think about conspiracy theories or theorists, you probably imagine a crazy person with a tin foil hat going on about how people in the government are lizards. You might also think about that meme from “It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia” where Charlie Day’s character scribbles over the wall like a madman.
But, not everyone who’s a theorist wears their tin foil dunce hat. In fact, some conspiracy theories have solid evidence and end up turning out to be true.
In a day and age where everything really isn’t as it seems, it’s important to not brush off some theorists, because many have actually turned out to be correct.
Below are just a few examples of conspiracies that have been proven true.
MK Ultra
Rumors that the U.S. government was making strides on mind control circulated during the 1960s. Those rumors sounded like something straight out of a science fiction novel. That was until government documents clarifying this dystopian idea were declassified in the 1970s.
From 1953 to 1973, the CIA conducted illegal and highly unethical experiments on unwitting U.S. citizens, according to a senate select committee. The agency administered LSD and other drugs to prisoners, psychiatric patients and even military personnel.
They utilized psychological torture and employed sensory deprivation in an attempt to develop mind control and interrogation techniques to use against the Soviet Union.
With other controversies surrounding government trust at the time the files were declassified, it was safe to say that many people’s trust in the federal government had been punched in the gut.
The ultimate false flag: Operation Northwoods
Believe it or not, U.S. military officials wanted to stage a terror attack on American soil targeting American civilians as an excuse to invade Cuba according to declassified files. The plan known as Operation Northwoods was a real drafted plan by U.S. military officials in 1962. It would’ve been an unthinkable notion that the military would create a plan that would kill American citizens, especially to justify a conflict with a man like Fidel Castro.
Castro had implied that he would be willing to destroy Cuba over surrendering to the U.S in a letter to Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev following the Bay of Pigs fiasco, which can be found on the JFK presidential library website.
Declassified documents revealed a proposed plan of committing acts of terrorism in major U.S. cities, including Miami, and blaming the attacks on Cuba to manufacture public support for a war against Castro. Again, The Bay of Pigs invasion had failed in dramatic fashion.
Thankfully, President John F. Kennedy rejected the plan, but the paperwork remains a chilling reminder of what military leaders were considering.
The Watergate cover-up
The Watergate cover up is the gold standard of modern political conspiracies. When a group of men broke into the Democratic National Committee headquarters at the Watergate complex in D.C. in 1972, it was initially dismissed as a third-rate burglary.
The idea that the president of the U.S. was intimately involved in a criminal espionage ring and a massive cover-up seemed far-fetched. To some, it may have even been seen as a poor attempt at pivoting by Democrats to blame the loss of 1968 and potential loss they would be facing in November on Republican sabotage.
It certainly wasn’t believable enough for most Americans in 1972, having virtually zero impact on President Richard Nixon’s historic landslide victory against George McGovern.
But thanks to relentless investigative journalism and subsequent congressional hearings, the public learned the truth. The conspiracy went all the way to the Oval Office, ultimately forcing Nixon to resign in 1974.
Unanswered questions
Other conspiracy theories that have yet to be proven true but have drawn massive speculation include Jeffrey Epstein’s suicide, the assassination of President Kennedy and the OJ Simpson murder case. Even with some of these cases being half a century old, they still raise questions about the trust people place in those in charge, and about cracks in the justice system.
With the recent release of the Epstein Files, many secret dealings and emails have been revealed about who Epstein dealt with over the years — including with prominent politicians and celebrities. There is further scrutiny over the security footage and guard logs on the night Epstein committed suicide in a New York jail, showing a three minute jump in time with not much explanation, also fueled speculation about whether he did kill himself or not.
In 1972, the house select committee found that there was likely a conspiracy to kill President Kennedy. Whether President Johnson, the Soviets, or any of the other groups theorized had been involved in the killing has never truly been determined, or even outright dismissed. Even 60 years later when President Donald Trump released new files about the assassination, no new information was revealed.
The entire world was glued to their TV sets in 1994, when former NFL Running back OJ Simpson was charged with the double murder of his ex-wife and her friend. Simpson was found not guilty in 1995, but the case officially remains unsolved. While several theories have been proposed, the main one still centers on Simpson.
These claims have been backed, for a lack of a better term, by the evidence used in the trial of the century. These include Simpson’s blood at the scene and the blood of both victims being found in a sock at his house — all pointing the bloody glove at him.
But it was his daring hypothetical confession, “If I Did It” that was released in the early 00’s, which details how Simpson would’ve likely killed Brown and Goldman that further fueled speculation. An interview with his former agent Mike Gilbert in the ESPN special “OJ: Made in America,” supports the widely accepted theory that Simpson was guilty.
In the final episode of the limited docu-series, Gilbert details the final night he and Simpson spent at the Rockingham Estate, the home Simpson lived in during the years before and after the murders.
Gilbert says he asked Simpson why he did it. Simpson calmly said, Gilbert claims, that had Brown not answered the door with a knife she would have lived.
Simpson died in Apr 2024 still publicly maintaining his innocence. Leaving one of the most famous murder cases in American history to remain permanently unresolved.
While most conspiracy theories on the internet today are baseless, history shows us that we shouldn’t blindly trust official narratives without question. Healthy skepticism is a vital part of democracy. Especially when something goes “unsolved” on the books like the Simpson case.
The next time someone brings up a wild theory, just remember: Even a broken clock is right twice a day.
