Opinion

Health care reform absolutely necessary

After an intense summer of legislative drama, Congress has once again failed to bring about meaningful change to our health care system. But one thing is for certain: our health-care crisis continues to worsen, with no end in sight.

With so many ideas flying around, politicians from both parties have asked, “Wouldn’t it be better to let the free market take care of the system?”  The answer should be a resounding “NO”.

Health care spending has skyrocketed in the past decade.  Everyone knows this.  More ominous is the fact that this unraveling of the system defied any attempts by the free market to control it.  The fact of the matter is standard free market principles are difficult to apply to health care.  This is not a typical supply-and-demand scenario.  For example, as health insurance rates increased,  many families predictably opted to purchase lower cost insurance with a higher deductible.  But while this may save them money for the moment, it also leaves them vulnerable to high costs and unexpected medical emergencies. In other words, they are one illness away from bankruptcy.  This system is hardly sustainable.

At the same time, our system is vastly inefficient. Most avenues of health care must first pass through an insurance company, and the very presence of this company adds so much more to the costs of health care, either through administrative costs or by the very fact that it’s a for-profit business.  This patchwork of private companies is ill-equipped to handle the ever-increasing burden of health care, which is expected to consume more than 20% of our GDP by 2018, and we remain one of the few remaining industrialized nations that have not adopted a single-payer system.

Any consumer-directed, market-driven system would have to take into account that the overwhelming majority of health care costs is spent on major operations, such as chemotherapy or heart surgery, that are performed not by choice, but because they will save a life.  It would be unfair, if not outrageous, to force people to pay for these expenses on their own, without help, and yet this is exactly what happens every day for those who are uninsured or underinsured.  While the cost of care continues to go up, mainly due to advances in medical technology, there is no reason to expect that these costs can be reined in using simple free-market solutions.  If the cost of soda increases, I can simply stop buying soda.  But if I’m a diabetic and the cost of my insulin goes up, can you really expect me to stop using insulin?

Many critics of reform point out that our current system protects the freedom to choose your own doctor and your own health insurance plan, but this freedom does little good if in a few years you can’t even afford such a plan in the first place.  Instead, the real “freedom” of choice is only enjoyed by those who can afford it and is in fact an illusion for the majority of us.

Health care is not a commodity.  In the same way that you cannot allow the whims of the market to decide the fate of a person’s life, we cannot allow our health care system sink further into privatization.  Although some may argue that health care is not a right guaranteed by the government, many countries from Costa Rica to Taiwan to Canada have recognized that health care is a basic human necessity and provide their citizens with some form of universal coverage.  And the same way that our government provides us with schools, fire stations, police, and public transit, we must ensure that every one of our citizens is protected by a fair and affordable health care system.  Right now, we could not be farther from that goal.  We must act, and we must act now.

August 26, 2009

Reporters

Melvin La

Contributing Columnist


Around the Web
  • Miami Herald
  • UM News
  • HurricaneSports

At their best, they are UM’s most dynamic players on each side of the ball. But the Ahmmon Richards ...

A day after practicing in the Carol Soffer Football Indoor Practice Facility for the first time in s ...

It appears that at least one LSU receiver won’t be available at the University of Miami football ope ...

After the Miami Hurricanes football team spent part of its practice on Monday in a torrential downpo ...

Nothing like a comic book cover on steroids to get University of Miami and LSU football fans juiced ...

Intergroup Dialogue, soon to be offered as a course, fosters a sense of belonging, an appreciation f ...

Aretha Franklin and her music defined “what is soul” to generations of music lovers. ...

The University of Miami kicked into high gear to welcome thousands of new students and ensure move-i ...

UM President Julio Frenk welcomes first-year and transfer students to UM in signature ’Cane Kickoff ...

Miami Law conducts its inaugural Legal Impact Hack for first-year students. ...

Playing in front of a boisterous home crowd, the University of Miami soccer team picked up a victory ...

The University of Miami volleyball team won its exhibition match over FIU, 3-0, Saturday at the Knig ...

Coming off a road win in its season opener, the University of Miami soccer team will welcome crossto ...

In head coach Sarah Barnes' debut at the helm, the University of Miami soccer team won its seas ...

The Hurricanes practiced in the Carol Soffer Indoor Practice Facility for the first time ever on Fri ...

TMH Twitter
About TMH

The Miami Hurricane is the student newspaper of the University of Miami in Coral Gables, Fla. The newspaper is edited and produced by undergraduate students at UM and is published weekly in print on Tuesdays during the regular academic year.