Edge

Movie Review Saw is the thriller of the week

A part of the marketing campaign for Saw has relied on comparisons made between the film and the 1995 hit Seven, a fellow edgy psychological thriller with horror movie ideals. Unfortunately, Saw is not Seven. It’s got plenty of the intensity, but is for the most part a pretty dumb movie.

As with many horror/thrillers, Saw puts regular people in horrific situations and lets the audience watch their reactions. But in Saw, the characters’ reactions are often times preposterous and extremely exaggerated versions of what would actually happen in real life. The filmmakers could justify this by saying that the setting is so unpredictable that it’s not fair to call it overacting, but some of the dialogue and decisions by characters are absurd.

On the surface, it’s psychologically terrifying, but most viewers could probably talk themselves out of being scared later on. Thankfully, the film holds back on the jumpy-scariness that has plagued modern horror films lately, and depends on its plot to be scary enough.

The story begins with two seemingly unconnected people waking up in a dilapidated public bathroom, each chained to pipes on opposite sides of the room. In the middle of the room lies the corpse of a man who has apparently shot himself in the head rather recently. One of the men is a middle-aged doctor, the other a dorky 20-something hipster. They start discovering clues in the room – things in their pockets, writing on the walls – that allow them to figure out more about the situation they’re in.

The film later reveals the man behind this, a serial murderer called the Jigsaw Killer. Jigsaw, a faceless psycho who’s become commonplace in these types of films, comes up with unique ways for his victims to die. One man is given a short amount of time to claw his way through a maze of barbed wire before the only exit slams shut. Another has a metal clamp attached to her face that will shred her jaw in half if she doesn’t rip the key out of the stomach of a semi-conscious man in under a minute.

Fun stuff, right? Finding new and exciting ways for people to get killed is a staple of the horror/thriller genre, evidenced by the popularity of the Final Destination films. Part of the reason Saw is such an engrossing film is that the viewer never knows what to expect. First-time director James Wan keeps the intensity level peaked for most of the film, and so no one will sink into boredom or watch-checking time.

The negatives go back to the dialogue and the acting. Normally refined thespian Cary Elwes (Shadow of a Vampire) plays the doctor character as a really over-the-top horror movie victim. Call it overacting or call it an honest reaction from someone placed in one of the worst situations, but Elwes goes overboard in a few scenes and makes some intense moments almost laughable. His counterpart is newcomer Leigh Whannell, also the film’s co-writer. His character is a bizarre, 20-something slacker who appears to be picked directly out of a Kevin Smith film and dropped into the horror world. Whannell’s dialogue is sometimes embarrassingly unrealistic, but he’s a fairly competent actor who might be great given the right material.

The real star of this film is the director, Wan. Saw contains a lot of original direction as far as the camerawork and style goes, and Wan has a promising future in the action and thriller genres. Saw is worth seeing for fans of the genre, and for anybody who likes a solid mystery thriller.

Shawn Wines can be contacted at s.wines@umiami.edu.

November 2, 2004

Reporters

The Miami Hurricane

Student newspaper at the University of Miami


Around the Web
  • Miami Herald
  • UM News
  • HurricaneSports

Three of four University of Miami scholarship quarterbacks were suspended at various times this seas ...

While the University of Miami offense has struggled mightily this season, its defense has been stell ...

The Pittsburgh Panthers boast one of the best rushing offenses in the country. On Saturday, the Miam ...

After watching several juniors turn pro and then go late in the draft or not at all in recent years, ...

A six-pack of Canes notes on a Monday: ▪ If you ever wondered what the Hurricanes would look like if ...

Erin Kobetz, director of Sylvester Comprehensive Cancer Center’s Firefighter Cancer Initiative, disc ...

Kristiana Yao, who graduated summa cum laude in May, said she was “still in shock” after finding out ...

UM Libraries is presenting an extraordinary exhibit that immerses the audience in an emotional journ ...

A UM researcher is helping to lead a study on how smoke interacts with clouds and its impact on the ...

People are bombarded with news and information these days, providing opportunities for discourse tha ...

The Miami women's basketball team jumped two spots to No. 22 nationally in the first in-season ...

The Canes got back to their winning ways with an impressive 38-14 victory at Virginia Tech. ...

The No. 24 Miami women's basketball team dropped a 75-52 decision Sunday at Iowa State in the P ...

20-point performances from Chris Lykes and DJ Vasiljevic led Miami past Bethune-Cookman. ...

The University of Miami volleyball team forced No. 10 Pitt to five sets in a thrilling match on Seni ...

TMH Twitter
About TMH

The Miami Hurricane is the student newspaper of the University of Miami in Coral Gables, Fla. The newspaper is edited and produced by undergraduate students at UM and is published weekly in print on Tuesdays during the regular academic year.