Opinion

Insufficient closure

Last April when freshmen Ashley Kelly and Andrea Cinque were hit by a car on U.S. 1 resulting in fatal injuries for Kelly, the UM community was shocked, saddened and moved into action. Many students were angered and expected the driver to be severely punished.

Kristin Arbuckle, the 25-year-old driver in question, received her sentence last week. After pleading guilty to running a red light, Arbuckle’s license was suspended for six months, and she must serve 50 hours of community service, attend an eight-hour traffic school course and pay a total of $323.50 in fines, court fees and a donation to a memorial scholarship fund set up in Kelly’s name.

This seemingly light punishment astonished the UM community. A young woman’s life is gone forever and the punishment is 50 hours of community service? Surely a life is worth more than that. Thoughts of how we would feel if our friend or family member was killed in a similar situation lead us to the immediate and emotional conclusion that we’d want someone to pay.

But after setting those initial thoughts aside and thinking about Arbuckle’s side of the issue there are many of us who should, with some reflection, be able to empathize with her, at least to a certain extent.

Every day a large portion of the UM student body drives to school, work, the mall, the beach or any other number of places. Many of us are in a hurry, not wanting to be late for class, a hot date or our favorite TV show. In our rush to get wherever we’re going, there are many of us who have pushed the speed limit a little (or a lot). Seeing a yellow light, there are at least some of us who have made the decision that yellow means go, not slow down.

For most of us, these decisions haven’t brought on any negative consequences, other than the fact that we don’t get in trouble, so we continue with our actions. For Arbuckle, her decision to run a red light-a decision that many of us could have made in our rush to be somewhere-ended in tragedy. That tragedy is something she will have to live with for the rest of her life.

Arbuckle pleaded guilty to running the light and didn’t fight the charges against her. In fact, our anger should not be directed at her but rather at the law. This case should be viewed as an opportunity to bring to light, and if deemed necessary to lobby against, Florida laws that protect drivers more than pedestrians.

For now, the legal system has decided that Arbuckle did not display a disregard for safety when she ran the light. While many of us may disagree with this decision, our legal system has made its decision. Part of the responsibility of the law is to stop people before they offend or re-offend. Rather than lambasting Arbuckle for her actions, no matter how angry we are, we should use her situation to guide our own decisions. We can’t change what happened, but we can help make sure it doesn’t happen again.

In the end, though, this isn’t about our outrage or agreement with the situation or punishment. It’s about a family that has to live with only the memories of their daughter. No amount of punishment, anger or regret can change that fact or bring about adequate closure for a grieving family. We keep the Kellys in our hearts.

September 23, 2005

Reporters

The Miami Hurricane

Student newspaper at the University of Miami


Around the Web
  • Miami Herald
  • UM News
  • HurricaneSports

It’s the play Miami Hurricanes fans will never forget — and Florida State fans are trying to forget. ...

Miami Hurricanes fans might recall their favorite college football players in past years dreaming of ...

The new quarterback is usually the ones fans gush over. For the University of Miami, last season it ...

Debate all you want, but University of Miami football coach Mark Richt made it clearer than ever Wed ...

Last year, when University of Miami tailback Mark Walton attended the Atlantic Coast Conference Foot ...

An ACLU report authored by UM sociologists documents racial and ethnic disparities in Miami-Dade Cou ...

Following the summit between Trump and Putin, reaction from politicians, pundits and former intellig ...

A School of Communication associate professor played an important hand—an artistic one!—in World Cup ...

University of Miami law and political science professors weigh in on Trump’s SCOTUS nominee. ...

Research bioclimatologists with the UM Synoptic Climatology Lab counsel cities on how to manage risi ...

Miami senior Tyler Gauthier was named to the 2018 Fall Watch List for the Rimington Trophy presented ...

Miami junior wide receiver Ahmmon Richards was among those named to the watch list for the 2018 Bile ...

University of Miami junior running back Travis Homer was named a preseason candidate for the Doak Wa ...

Six former Canes competed on NBA Summer League teams, with three averaging at least 10 points per ga ...

Quick Hits gives University of Miami volleyball fans an opportunity to get to know the new student-a ...

TMH Twitter
About TMH

The Miami Hurricane is the student newspaper of the University of Miami in Coral Gables, Fla. The newspaper is edited and produced by undergraduate students at UM and is published weekly in print on Tuesdays during the regular academic year.